Call Today: (704) 931-8801
If you want to start doing SEO or are already doing it, you may consider outsourcing your digital marketing to an SEO company. An SEO consultant can help your business improve online visibility, boost organic traffic, and generate leads. However, with SEO being a long-term investment, you want to ensure your SEO company works effectively. So, how can you tell if they’re genuinely delivering results?
Here are some key signs to help you tell if your SEO company is doing a good job:
An experienced SEO agency will communicate clearly and consistently. They should provide regular updates on project status, strategy adjustments, and any new recommendations. Look for an agency that sets up clear communication channels and gives you a dedicated point of contact. Whether through weekly check-ins, monthly reporting, or email summaries, good communication is essential.
A quality SEO company will provide transparent reports on a regular basis, typically monthly. The reports should highlight key metrics such as:
Tip: If your SEO company is evasive or fails to provide clear answers, or if their reporting lacks essential data, this could be a red flag.
While traffic and visibility are crucial, they should ultimately lead to conversions, whether completing a form, contacting your company, signing up for a newsletter, or making a purchase.
Your SEO company should work with you to track and measure conversions. They might use tools like Google Analytics to set up “key events” on your site, helping you understand users’ actions, such as filling out forms or downloading content.
Beyond bringing in traffic, an effective SEO agency will help optimize your site to convert that traffic. This includes:
Tip: If you see higher traffic but not more conversions, ask your SEO company to examine optimization opportunities.
An effective SEO agency will also focus on on-page optimization and content quality. This includes:
Tip: On-page optimization should be a continuous process, and you should see these efforts reflected in improved page visibility and user engagement over time.
Technical SEO is vital for ensuring your website is user-friendly, accessible, and well-optimized for search engines. Your SEO provider should:
Technical issues can hinder your SEO progress, so an attentive agency will prioritize fixing these elements.
Tip: If your site is loading faster, functioning smoothly on mobile, and free of major errors, it’s a sign your agency is doing a good job.
SEO isn’t static; search engines frequently update algorithms, and competitive landscapes shift. Your SEO company should stay up-to-date with changes and adapt your strategy as needed. They should be proactive in making adjustments, whether it’s targeting new keywords, updating old content, or refining link-building efforts.
Tip: A good SEO agency will continuously test, learn, and improve. They’ll explain their adjustments and the rationale behind them to keep you informed and confident in their approach.
SEO is a long-term strategy, and your agency should be focused on sustainable results rather than “quick fixes.” An effective SEO company will show gradual, consistent improvement in key metrics over time rather than dramatic spikes that quickly fade. SEO growth may seem slow initially, but you should see measurable progress within 6 to 12 months.
Tip: Ask for case studies or examples of past successes they’ve achieved for similar businesses. A strong agency will demonstrate how their efforts have translated into lasting results for other clients, demonstrating that they can do the same for you.
If you want a successful SEO campaign, ensuring your SEO strategy aligns with your core business goals is essential. While search rankings can be an appealing measure of progress, focusing solely on rank can be misleading. It’s possible to rank high for a specific term and yet see little to no increase in customers or sales. Rankings alone don’t guarantee meaningful engagement or conversions, and a “rank-centric” approach often overlooks the larger objective of SEO—driving real business growth.
Additionally, search rankings are not static. They fluctuate with algorithm updates, competitive shifts, and changing search trends. An effective SEO strategy centers on creating sustainable, long-term value rather than chasing temporary ranking gains. This involves consistently refining your website’s usability, publishing valuable content, and optimizing conversion paths that lead to customer action.
Instead, evaluate your SEO services based on meaningful outcomes like customer acquisition, lead generation, and sales growth. A high-performing SEO agency will prioritize these outcomes, working to bring in the right kind of traffic: visitors who are actually interested in your products or services and are more likely to become paying customers. Keeping these metrics in mind ensures that your SEO efforts directly contribute to business success, not just search engine placement.
Evaluating an SEO company’s performance is essential to ensure they’re helping you reach your business goals. The right SEO agency will act as a partner, bringing transparency, expertise, and a commitment to helping your business succeed online. By consistently monitoring the above signs, you can feel confident that your SEO company is doing a good job for you.
Want to Make Sure Your SEO is Driving Real Results?
Partner with Reliable Acorn for transparent, data-driven SEO that delivers. Contact us today for a free website audit and see how we can help your business succeed.
David Zimmerman has earned his Google Analytics Certification.
Learn why we're reliable.
Read our other credentials.
Reliable Acorn will help you create a custom digital marketing strategy that does just that.
Ready to Talk?